Should the insanity defense protect defendants from criminal penalty?
Answers:
If through mental disease or defect, a person is incapable of sympathy that their actions were unofficial, it's a reasonable defense. The problem is how to judge that. I imagine a mandatory stay in a psychiatric unit for the permanent status they would have stayed in send down might deter frivolous claims of insanity.
I believe it should provided you really were/are insane. I believe that lasting thing could drive an otherwise sane person to acting insanity. If somebody were to murder somebody I deeply care about, It MIGHT drive me to temporary insanity, I couldn't right to be heard what I would do. If you are permanently insane, you should probably be locked in a hospital or something to protect society, but otherwise, you should be consent to free.
Have you ever seen the prisoner section of a mental hospital or the hospital screened-off area of a prison? Neither is a nice place. And how much rehabilitation can someone have if they are out of contact with the world and/or themselves.
For concepts of sprite, yes, there should be an insanity defense. For making criminal prosecution easier, perhaps not.
It might be an eye introductory encounter if you see how few people get out of criminal charges through an insanity plea.. Get contained by touch with your local criminal prosecutor`s office.
Related Questions: